The tragic demise of Assamese music icon Zubeen Garg has not only plunged the state into mourning but also triggered a storm of controversy surrounding the circumstances of his death. Amid growing public outrage and mounting allegations against event organiser Shyamkanu Mahanta and Zubeen’s manager Siddharth Sharma, former Assam Director General of Police (DGP) Violet Baruah has made a striking statement: “Police arrest might be the safest option.”
Baruah’s comment, shared via a viral Facebook post, has added a new dimension to the ongoing investigation. She expressed concern over procedural loopholes that could potentially shield the accused, urging the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) to invoke Section 238 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita—pertaining to disappearance of evidence or provision of false information. Her post has sparked widespread debate, with many echoing her call for accountability and swift action.
Zubeen Garg, 52, passed away on September 19 in Singapore following a scuba diving accident while attending the North East Festival. Despite his fragile health, he was reportedly allowed to travel overseas without adequate medical arrangements. Critics allege that Mahanta, who coordinated the festival, prioritized business meetings over Zubeen’s well-being. Siddharth Sharma, Zubeen’s manager, was also present during the trip and is now under scrutiny.
Key Allegations in Zubeen Garg’s Death Investigation
| Individual Involved | Role in Incident | Allegations Raised |
|---|---|---|
| Shyamkanu Mahanta | Event Organiser | Negligence, prioritizing business over safety |
| Siddharth Sharma | Zubeen’s Manager | Failure to ensure medical support, poor oversight |
| Singapore Police | Local Authority | Interrogated Mahanta, Sharma, and 9 others |
| Assam CID | Investigating Agency | Registered case, yet to invoke Section 238 |
The CID has launched a formal investigation following multiple complaints filed across Assam. Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma acknowledged the seriousness of the allegations, stating that they “cannot be dismissed outright.” He confirmed that both Mahanta and Sharma will be thoroughly investigated, and that the state government will ensure transparency in the process.
Baruah’s statement has resonated deeply with the public, many of whom view Zubeen not just as a singer but as a cultural symbol of Assamese identity. “He was like a mischievous child at home, someone who carried the soul of Assam in his voice,” Baruah wrote, expressing personal grief and professional concern. Her call for arrests is seen as a push for accountability in a case that risks being diluted by procedural delays.
Public Reaction to Former IGP’s Statement
| Stakeholder Group | Reaction Summary | Sentiment Indicator |
|---|---|---|
| General Public | Supportive of arrest call, demanding justice | High concern |
| Cultural Community | Mourning Zubeen’s loss, demanding transparency | Emotional outrage |
| Legal Experts | Mixed views on arrest timing, support Section 238 | Cautious optimism |
| Political Leaders | Divided along party lines, some call for restraint | Politically charged |
The controversy has also reignited discussions about artist welfare and event management ethics. Many are questioning why Zubeen, known to be unwell, was permitted to travel abroad for a high-pressure performance. Activists have demanded stricter protocols for artist travel and health monitoring, especially for senior performers.
Singapore Police had earlier interrogated Mahanta, Sharma, and nine others connected to the incident. Mahanta himself acknowledged the questioning but denied any wrongdoing, stating that “all arrangements were in place” and that Zubeen “insisted on performing.” However, leaked footage and eyewitness accounts suggest that Zubeen appeared visibly fatigued and disoriented before his final performance.
Timeline of Events Leading to Zubeen Garg’s Death
| Date | Event Description | Location |
|---|---|---|
| Sep 17 | Zubeen arrives in Singapore for North East Festival | Singapore |
| Sep 18 | Performs despite health concerns | Festival Venue |
| Sep 19 | Goes scuba diving, loses consciousness | Singapore coast |
| Sep 19 | Declared dead after failed resuscitation | Local hospital |
| Sep 20 | CID registers case, public protests erupt | Assam |
| Sep 21 | Former IGP calls for arrests, Section 238 invocation | Social media |
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita’s Section 238, which Baruah referenced, deals with the disappearance of evidence or provision of false information during investigations. Legal experts believe its invocation could strengthen the case and prevent tampering or evasion. “It’s a powerful provision that ensures accountability. If the CID includes it, the investigation gains teeth,” said Guwahati-based lawyer Anupam Das.
Meanwhile, protests have erupted across Assam, with fans and cultural groups demanding justice for Zubeen. Candlelight vigils, street marches, and social media campaigns have intensified, turning the case into a statewide movement. Hashtags like #JusticeForZubeen and #ArrestMahanta have trended for days, reflecting the public’s emotional investment.
Social Media Sentiment Analysis – Zubeen Garg Case
| Platform | Trending Hashtags | Sentiment Summary |
|---|---|---|
| #JusticeForZubeen, #ArrestMahanta | 70% support for arrest, 20% demand inquiry | |
| Tribute reels, protest posters | Emotional, nostalgic, justice-driven | |
| Long-form posts, debates | Mixed but leaning toward accountability | |
| YouTube | Tribute videos, case explainers | High engagement, calls for transparency |
The state government has assured that no stone will be left unturned. CM Sarma has directed the CID to expedite the investigation and submit a preliminary report within 10 days. He also hinted at possible administrative reforms in event management protocols to prevent similar tragedies.
As the investigation unfolds, the spotlight remains on whether arrests will be made and whether Section 238 will be invoked. Violet Baruah’s statement has undoubtedly shifted the narrative, placing pressure on authorities to act decisively. For Assam, Zubeen Garg was more than a singer—he was a voice of identity, rebellion, and emotion. His death demands not just mourning, but justice.
Disclaimer: This article is based on publicly available statements, media reports, and legal commentary. It does not reflect any political stance or endorsement. All quotes are attributed to public figures as per coverage. The content is intended for editorial and informational purposes only.
